Observation Dome

Editing Trouble

The whole Thomas Allman sequence at the start of The Inquisitor... wouldn't that have been so much better before the credits, as per the script?



There's something that's always troubled me about the Thomas Allman sequence, and now I can't remember what it is...

... oh yeah, that's it. HE NEVER GETS A TRIAL. What's that all about?

By Seb Patrick [TypeKey Profile Page] on 04-08-05 @ 19:57

It's veeeery dodgy plotting is that. Either it was written before decided on the whole trial thing, or they just realised that dramatically any trial stuff at the start just wouldn't work.

One possible way of explaining it away is that he used not to give proper trials, but after visiting Earth in the early 21st century got very scared about the abuses of justice and resolved to do things more fairly.


By John Hoare [TypeKey Profile Page] on 04-08-05 @ 20:07

Perhaps the trial only takes place in the person's mind. In the episode we are not privy to Allman's thoughts but we are for the crew. Maybe.

By Smeghead2044 on 04-08-05 @ 20:29

Fair enough, Smeghead. I always just rationalized it to myself that he received a trial but had his memory of it erased, and the Inquisitor is just popping back to finish the job. But Smeghead's explanation makes more sense.

Still, John's social commentary bit would be nice.

By Phil Reed on 04-08-05 @ 21:42

Post a comment


(required, but will not be displayed)


Remember Me?

Simple XHTML is allowed; you can use: <a href=""> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <blockquote> <img /> <br />.

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:

RSS 1.0 Feed RSS 2.0 Feed Atom 0.3 Feed Livejournal Syndication